Medical Aid vs Health Insurance

Medical aid and health insurance sound similar but are two distinct products under South African law, with different regulators and very different protections. A medical aid (medical scheme) is regulated by the Council for Medical Schemes. Health insurance is an insurance product regulated by the Financial Sector Conduct Authority. Confusing the two can leave you seriously underinsured. This is a plain-language explainer by an FSCA-registered broker (FSP 44098).

Medical aid (a medical scheme)

A medical aid is a registered medical scheme regulated by the Council for Medical Schemes under the Medical Schemes Act 131 of 1998. It rests on three protections: open enrolment, meaning the scheme must accept you regardless of age or health; community rating, meaning everyone on the same option pays the same contribution regardless of age or health; and Prescribed Minimum Benefits, a defined set of conditions every option must cover in full. It pays your actual medical costs, subject to your plan rules.

Health insurance

Health insurance is an insurance product, licensed by the Prudential Authority and supervised for market conduct by the Financial Sector Conduct Authority under the insurance laws, and permitted alongside medical schemes by the demarcation regulations that took effect on 1 April 2017. Typical examples are hospital cash plans and primary-care insurance. It usually pays a fixed cash amount (for example a set rand value per day in hospital) rather than your actual medical bill. It can be risk-rated, which means the insurer can price on your age or health and can decline or cancel cover. It does not have to cover Prescribed Minimum Benefits, and it is not a substitute for a medical aid.

Where does gap cover fit in?

Gap cover is a separate insurance product under the same demarcation regulations. It is designed to top up an existing medical aid, mainly covering the shortfall between what in-hospital specialists charge and what your scheme pays. It is capped at an annual limit set by regulation and adjusted each year, and it cannot stand alone: you must have a medical aid for gap cover to work.

The important warning

Health insurance is not medical aid. Because it pays a fixed amount and can decline or cancel you on health grounds, relying on it instead of a medical scheme can leave you dangerously short if you have a serious illness or a long hospital stay. As a base, everyone who can afford it should have a registered medical scheme option, even a hospital plan. Health insurance is best used as a low-cost supplement or as a stopgap for those who genuinely cannot afford a scheme.

Is health insurance the same as medical aid?

No. Medical aid is a medical scheme regulated by the Council for Medical Schemes that pays your actual medical costs and must cover Prescribed Minimum Benefits. Health insurance is an FSCA-regulated insurance product that pays a fixed cash amount and does not have to cover Prescribed Minimum Benefits. They are different products with different protections.

Can health insurance replace medical aid?

No. Health insurance pays limited fixed amounts and can be declined or cancelled based on your health, so it can leave a large shortfall on a serious claim. It is a supplement, not a replacement for a registered medical scheme.

Is gap cover health insurance or medical aid?

Gap cover is an insurance product under the demarcation regulations. It is not medical aid and cannot stand alone. It tops up an existing medical aid by covering in-hospital specialist shortfalls, up to an annual limit set by regulation.

Want help choosing the right combination of medical aid and gap cover?